Apparently a mod consensus was reached that these games aren't being refunded, because it'd give the town a higher chance of winning and in the long run, due more damage. Sorry.

Rocky, Riddler is Redmage. I filed an appeal concerning the "trolling Riddler" remark. As jailer, the way to troll riddler is to jailkill n1. Not to wait until it looks like town is going to lose and to play kingmaker. I didn't realize that is what I was doing, because what Riddler was saying didn't make sense to me. I just figured he was trying to get out of being killed, an I referenced the OGI he was using, which made me for sure hammer him. This should probably be refunded, and I should probably receive the violation, but this was in no way a trolling Riddler maneuver, and I would like it if that wasn't a note about this situation

I know, but how is he trolling riddler, when he wasnt in this game?

Wait who's Riddler?

http://www.epicmafia.com/report/35264

Same scenario,worse description, different justice...why?

That doesn't make sense to me? My thought was that maf was going to try and kill redmage, so if I killed him, then maf wouldn't have a kill.

Sorry, this type of confusion about gamethrowing is why manhunt should not be comped

he could've won if he didnt killed

Give him vio and refund the game. Totally wasnt fair.